New York’s highest court is hearing arguments over a controversial city law that would allow noncitizens to vote in municipal elections. If upheld, more than 800,000 noncitizens could gain the ability to vote in races like the mayoral election.
Key Facts:
- The New York City Council passed a law allowing noncitizens to vote in city-level elections.
- If approved, over 800,000 noncitizens could register to vote.
- Proponents argue that noncitizens pay taxes and should have a say in local governance.
- The state constitution states that voting rights are for “every citizen.”
- An appellate court ruled against the law last year, siding with Republicans.
CLICK HERE TO GET A FREE COPY OF THE ESSENTIAL FEDERALIST PAPERS’
The Rest of The Story:
New York’s highest court is now reviewing whether noncitizens should be allowed to vote in city elections.
Advocates of the law claim that because noncitizens pay billions in taxes, they should have a voice in city matters such as public safety and housing.
However, Republican lawmakers and critics argue that voting is a right reserved exclusively for U.S. citizens, as outlined in the state constitution.
A lower court previously ruled against the law, stating that the constitution implicitly excludes noncitizens from voting.
The legal challenge comes as New York City grapples with a massive influx of illegal immigrants, straining resources and sparking local outrage over migrant housing policies.
NYC is set to grant over 800,000 non-citizens the right to vote.
New York City Councilman Joe Borelli blasted the proposal, "It dilutes the voting power of the 5.6 million registered voters in New York City." pic.twitter.com/OkrBbrma7D
— NEWSMAX (@NEWSMAX) November 28, 2021
Commentary:
The idea that noncitizens should have a say in elections is absurd.
Voting is not simply about taxation—it is about citizenship.
If someone wants to participate in shaping the laws and policies of this country, the clear path is to become a citizen.
CLICK HERE TO GET A FREE COPY OF THE ESSENTIAL FEDERALIST PAPERS’
There is no justification for allowing noncitizens—who have not sworn allegiance to the United States—to influence elections.
New York City’s attempt to extend voting rights to noncitizens is a blatant undermining of the principle that elections should be decided by American citizens.
The law’s supporters argue that noncitizens pay taxes and should have representation, but this is misleading.
Tourists, temporary workers, and even illegal immigrants also pay some taxes.
That does not entitle them to vote.
Voting is not a benefit—it is a fundamental right reserved for those who have committed themselves to the nation.
This legal battle is about more than just New York City; it sets a dangerous precedent.
If noncitizens can vote in local elections today, what stops activists from pushing to expand their voting rights to state and even federal elections?
The integrity of the electoral system depends on clear, enforceable rules—rules that should not be rewritten to appease political agendas.
The Bottom Line:
New York’s attempt to allow noncitizens to vote is a direct challenge to the state constitution and the very concept of citizenship.
If the courts uphold this law, it could open the door to a broader erosion of voting rights reserved for American citizens.
This case is about protecting the integrity of elections and ensuring that only those who are legally part of the nation have a say in its future.
CLICK HERE TO GET A FREE COPY OF THE ESSENTIAL FEDERALIST PAPERS’
Read Next
– Pete Hegseth Shakes Up the Pentagon Press Room, Legacy Media Calls It ‘Deeply Shocking’
– Trump Expands His Lawsuit Against CBS News After Release of Unedited 60 Minutes Interview
– Former Anheuser-Busch President Spills the Beans on Bud Light’s Recovery Post-Mulvaney