NBC Universal Settles $30M Defamation Suit Case Against MSNBC, Rachel Maddow

NBCUniversal has quietly settled a massive defamation lawsuit after MSNBC hosts, including Rachel Maddow, Nicolle Wallace, and Chris Hayes, falsely accused a Georgia doctor of performing “mass hysterectomies” on immigrant women. The case, which revealed internal doubts at the network about the claims, was settled for an undisclosed amount, avoiding a jury trial.

Key Facts:

NBCUniversal settled a defamation lawsuit filed by Dr. Mahendra Amin over MSNBC’s false reporting on April 22.
MSNBC hosts, including Maddow, dubbed Amin the “uterus collector” in 2020, falsely accusing him of performing mass hysterectomies on immigrant women.
A federal judge found that MSNBC made 39 “verifiably false” statements and acted with “actual malice.”
Discovery revealed MSNBC journalists had early doubts about the whistleblower’s claims but ran the story anyway.
The case follows CNN’s $5 million defamation loss and a potential CBS settlement with Donald Trump over deceptive reporting.

The Rest of The Story:

Dr. Mahendra Amin sued MSNBC for defamation in 2021 after the network accused him of conducting unnecessary and unauthorized medical procedures on female detainees at an ICE facility.

These claims were based on a whistleblower complaint from former nurse Dawn Wooten, but internal MSNBC messages revealed journalists themselves questioned the allegations.

Despite these doubts, the network aggressively pushed the story, amplifying its anti-Trump narrative.

The case nearly went to trial before NBCUniversal settled, preventing further exposure of internal emails and text messages that showed MSNBC hosts had played a direct role in promoting the false claims.

The lawsuit is one of several recent high-profile defamation cases against mainstream media networks, signaling a growing trend of legal consequences for reckless reporting.

NBC Universal has agreed to settle a $30m defamation lawsuit after its MSNBC talent lied and said a Georgia doctor was performing Mengele-style “mass hysterectomies” at an ICE facility during the first Trump administration.@chrislhayes, Rachel @maddow, Nicole Wallace, and… pic.twitter.com/zLLNcfmUHU

— Andy Ngo (@MrAndyNgo) February 22, 2025

Commentary:

For years, mainstream media figures operated under the assumption that they could smear individuals with impunity, particularly when those stories served a political agenda.

MSNBC’s reckless reporting on Dr. Amin was not an accident—it was a deliberate effort to push a damaging narrative against the Trump administration.

The lawsuit exposed how even MSNBC’s own journalists had serious doubts about the story, but the network aired it anyway because it fit their preferred storyline.

This is part of a broader pattern.

CNN was recently forced to pay $5 million for falsely portraying a Navy veteran as a criminal, and CBS may soon settle with Trump over a manipulated interview clip.

The media establishment believed it was untouchable, shielded by ideological allies in government and the press.

That illusion has now been shattered.

The fact that NBC settled suggests they feared losing in court, especially after a judge ruled that the network made “verifiably false” claims.

These lawsuits send a clear message—corporate media outlets can no longer lie without consequence.

The days of one-sided smears with no accountability are over.

MSNBC’s credibility continues to erode.

The same network spent years pushing the false Trump-Russia collusion hoax, and now they’ve been caught again fabricating a story to fit their agenda.

Settlements like this one are a wake-up call: if you spread lies, you will pay.