Zohran Mamdani, a socialist candidate running for New York City mayor, once said domestic violence incidents shouldn’t involve police. In a 2020 podcast, he pushed for crisis responders instead of armed officers—despite NYPD handling over 110,000 such cases in 2024.
Key Facts:
- Zohran Mamdani is a current NYC mayoral candidate and sitting state assemblyman representing Queens.
- In a 2020 podcast, Mamdani said police shouldn’t respond to domestic violence incidents, favoring unarmed “crisis responders.”
- His campaign platform includes replacing police with unarmed mental health professionals in undefined “crisis” situations.
- The NYPD logged more than 110,000 domestic violence calls in 2024, concentrated in minority-heavy, lower-income neighborhoods.
- Experts warn Mamdani’s policy could endanger women and increase homicide rates linked to intimate partner violence.
The Rest of The Story:
During a 2020 appearance on the Immigrantly podcast, Mamdani said police aren’t the right response for a range of issues—including domestic violence.
“There are so many different situations that would be far better handled by people trained to deal with those specific situations, as opposed to an individual with a gun,” he said.
This statement resurfaced as Mamdani pushes a platform to replace police in “mental health” cases with non-police crisis teams.
His plan is vague on definitions, and his campaign did not respond to multiple requests for clarification about whether this includes domestic violence.
Women’s advocacy groups and former law enforcement leaders are alarmed.
Sonia Ossorio, president of the New York City chapter of the National Organization for Women, said, “The idea of removing police protection is outrageous… uninformed and dangerous.”
Studies back that up.
A 2021 study in the World Journal of Psychiatry found intimate partner violence is the leading cause of homicide death for women in the U.S., especially affecting young women, minorities, and the disabled.
And 2024 NYPD data shows over 110,000 domestic violence incidents—many in underserved, high-crime communities.
Veteran NYPD homicide detective Pete Panuccio didn’t mince words: “Homicide rates will increase, women will be pulverized… There will be no defense for at-risk people. I’ve been in this bad movie before.”
Commentary:
Ask any police officer what the most unpredictable, dangerous calls are, and you’ll hear the same answer: domestic violence.
Officers walk into homes not knowing if there’s a weapon, a volatile aggressor, or a child in harm’s way.
Replacing them with social workers? That’s beyond reckless—it’s a ticking time bomb.
Suggesting that someone “trained in mental health” should handle these calls without backup is not just naive, it’s a gamble with real lives.
A bruised mother can’t be rescued with a clipboard and a counseling degree.
She needs immediate protection—often at gunpoint—from someone who’s trained to de-escalate and, if necessary, fight.
This is where Mamdani’s utopian fantasy crumbles into dystopian policy.
He’s pushing a social experiment with the highest stakes imaginable—people’s lives.
And the people most at risk are often women in marginalized communities, the very ones progressives claim to champion.
Even worse, Mamdani’s rhetoric reflects a deep-rooted ideology.
He calls the NYPD an “occupying force,” accuses them of racism and bigotry, and says they “amplify violence.”
These aren’t policy tweaks—this is Marxist deconstructionism disguised as reform.
Mamdani’s views may earn applause in far-left circles, but they are far removed from the daily reality of violence that plagues parts of New York.
His policies could pull away the last line of defense for victims while offering no viable replacement.
Let’s not forget: social workers didn’t sign up to be shields.
Sending them into explosive situations without police backup is setting them up for trauma—or worse.
It’s also a cruel joke on victims who need real help, not theory.
If New York chooses Mamdani as mayor, they’re not just electing a new leader—they’re volunteering for a dangerous experiment that sacrifices safety for ideology.
The Bottom Line:
Zohran Mamdani wants to pull police out of domestic violence calls, replacing them with unarmed crisis responders.
With over 100,000 such cases annually in NYC—many involving life-or-death situations—this plan isn’t reform, it’s a recipe for disaster.
Mamdani’s anti-police agenda might play well in activist circles, but for everyday New Yorkers, it could mean more blood on the sidewalk and fewer people around to stop it.
Read Next
– Trump Amin Ending Taxpayer Funded Gravy Train For Illegal Aliens In Postsecondary Education
– Federal Aid for Americans Only: HHS Dismantles Backdoor Benefits for Illegals
– Ambassador Who Held Her Head in Disgust During Trump Meeting Just Lost Her Job
– DNC Chair Gives Insane Answer When Asked Why Mamdami Didn’t Condemn Phrase ‘Globalize The Intifada’
– Judge Bypasses SCOTUS Limits, Grants Sweeping Injunction Against Trump Birthright Citizenship Order
